Federal Unemployment Benefits Cut Off Early; Workers Struggling to Find Jobs

Debi Jacks and her two teenage daughters are more likely to lose their dwelling quickly. 

The federal eviction moratorium ends July 31, and with no job, no extra unemployment advantages, and lease that’s already late, her outlook is bleak.

Jacks, 51, lives along with her daughters in an Oklahoma Metropolis house. She was a structural welder for 25 years earlier than she misplaced her son in late 2018. 

After taking all the subsequent 12 months off to deal with psychological well being challenges, she launched a service lending single mothers an additional hand as a housekeeper, prepare dinner or tackling different odd jobs. 

However months after launching her enterprise, Two-of-You, in January 2022, the COVID-19 pandemic struck. 

Jacks was compelled to close down and needed to depend on state and federal unemployment to get by whereas she seemed for one more job. 

Thus far, she hasn’t landed one.

With the Federal Pandemic Unemployment Compensation advantages ending final month, a decent labor market means hundreds of unemployed Oklahomans, like Jacks, are nonetheless struggling to search out work.

However enterprise homeowners, particularly these within the service trade, say they nonetheless have former workers on unemployment and are having a tough time discovering staff to fill the vacant positions. The issue is protecting them from opening utterly, and in some instances stopping companies from opening in any respect. 

David Riesenburg owns Oklahoma Metropolis’s Belle Isle Restaurant and Brewery. 

In March 2022, the restaurant closed in response to a mandate limiting in-door gatherings. Upon reopening for curbside and take-out companies, Riesenburg allowed his workers to decide on in the event that they needed to work or not, whether or not it was as a result of they feared the virus, or they weren’t getting sufficient hours as a consequence of decreased enterprise. The restaurant has been severely understaffed since. 

Riesenburg mentioned he nonetheless has former workers on unemployment and needs they might return to work. With out the additional advantages, he thinks they only would possibly.

His restaurant has three areas within the 50 Penn Place mall, solely one in all which is open due to the sunshine employees. He mentioned the faucet room above the primary diner is simply open for ticketed exhibits. He talked about a very busy occasion the place he needed to have further assist. 

“I had 22 folks working that day between the upstairs and the downstairs,” he mentioned. “Of my workers, I had 18 of them and 4 different those that didn’t work for me that had been brothers, or boyfriends and girlfriends of employees, simply to assist us deal with enterprise.” 

Since Gov. Kevin Stitt’s announcement in May, Oklahoma joined two dozen different Republican-led states in ending a $300-a-week federal supplemental unemployment profit, generally known as FPUC, and one other federal profit aimed toward serving to gig staff known as the Pandemic Unemployment Help, or PUA. 

He mentioned his resolution was meant to assist employers like Riesenburg discover staff and improve below-standard labor participation charges. However because the unemployment and labor participation charges attain ranges near what they had been earlier than the pandemic, a decent labor market means closing the employment hole isn’t nearly how a lot Oklahomans are amassing in unemployment advantages.

What the Numbers Present

Shelley Zumwalt, govt director of the Oklahoma Employment Safety Fee, mentioned the state has been seeing file job opening charges this 12 months. 

That mirrors what’s going on nationally. In line with the Bureau of Labor Statistics’ latest data, there have been a file 9.2 million job openings throughout the nation on the finish of Could. That’s up from about 5.5 million job openings at the moment final 12 months. 

Shelley Zumwalt, govt director of the Oklahoma Employment Safety Fee. (Courtesy picture)

“The administration needed to take motion,” Zumwalt mentioned. “Now we have employers which might be attempting to remain open, and they aren’t discovering candidates. So how can we join employers and workers, and what (does the administration) have management over in that situation?”

She mentioned the reply, now that companies have the choice to completely open, is unemployment advantages — who receives them, and what sort of coaching alternatives exist for these prepared and capable of take part.

Transfer Faces Authorized Problem

Oklahoma is one in all 25 states that ended federal dietary supplements to unemployment payouts. In Indiana, the place staff sued Gov. Eric Holcomb for the transfer, a state court docket dominated that Holcomb’s resolution was in violation of Indiana regulation and mentioned it prompted irreparable hurt to Hoosiers by taking away their capability to pay for requirements similar to lease, utilities, groceries and fundamental medical care. 

Indiana appealed and requested {that a} new choose hear the case; the state argues that reinstatement of the advantages will delay the financial restoration and hurt Hoosiers extra in the long term.

Now, unemployed Oklahomans face the identical destiny of us in Indiana are combating to keep away from — lawsuit and all. 

On July 7, Tulsa County resident Ronda Kay Owens petitioned for a declaratory judgement and injunctive reduction towards Zumwalt in her official capability as the chief director of the Oklahoma Employment Safety Fee. Within the petition, Owens’ legal professional, Chadwick Smith, argues her place on three grounds:

  • The Oklahoma Employment Safety Fee is an impartial state company created by the Legislature. Nowhere within the Oklahoma Employment Security Act is the governor granted coverage, administrative, or enforcement authority over the fee or Zumwalt.
  • The Fee exists to offer unemployment advantages to Oklahomans who qualify, and assist them discover jobs, to not work as a automobile to implement political coverage aimed toward financial restoration or construct a business-friendly surroundings within the state. 
  • OESC has a statutory necessary obligation to hunt the federal dietary supplements for unemployed Oklahomans. The Oklahoma Employment Safety Act states that the fee is to take all benefits below the Social Safety Act, of which the Coronavirus Help, Reduction, and Financial Safety Act is an extension. 

Zumwalt mentioned the company can’t touch upon pending litigation, whereas Owens has been directed by her legal professional to not remark to the media.

The case will probably be heard July 20 by District Court docket Choose William J. Musseman. 

However Owens isn’t the one Oklahoman suing the federal government over unemployment. Not less than one different lawsuit has been filed towards Stitt and the Oklahoma Employment Safety Fee. This lawsuit asks the Oklahoma Supreme Court docket to straight order the OESC to revive the federal advantages and is predicted to be heard on Aug. 11. The listening to will happen after the federal advantages expire, however can set the precedent for related instances. 

Hundreds Search Assist, Solutions 

Jeri “Jae” Robinson-Guthrie, 49, misplaced her two jobs as a advertising merchandiser in 2019 and, having been unemployed earlier than, was acquainted with the method and filed an unemployment insurance coverage declare. After spending about 4 weeks ready for her declare to be adjudicated, she joined the Oklahoma Unemployment Points Fb group and have become an administrator shortly after. 

With greater than 7,000 members, Robinson-Guthrie mentioned she thought there have been too many Oklahomans needing assist for her to not volunteer as an admin. She lastly discovered a paid job in early July as a distant banking customer support consultant, however has spent the final 12 months changing into an skilled in state unemployment advantages and serving to Oklahomans navigate the method. As a result of federal unemployment dietary supplements ended June 27, greater than 100,000 Oklahomans are scrambling to learn how they are going to pay for fundamental requirements. 

Jeri “Jae” Robinson-Guthrie. (Courtesy picture)

Robinson-Guthrie mentioned each unemployment declare is exclusive and that the explanations persons are on unemployment fluctuate from having misplaced their jobs and caring concerning the pandemic to not getting access to baby care, or being too previous, too skilled, residing too far-off, or having beforehand labored in an trade that doesn’t exist on the similar capability.

She mentioned she is aware of there are folks sitting again and simply drawing an unemployment examine, however that no unemployed Oklahomans had been consulted by the federal government to search out out what most individuals are going by means of within the state, so there was no apparent try and attempt to stability the implications of the choice.

“There’s those that at all times milk the system; there’s those that after they work, they milk the time clock,” Robinson-Guthrie mentioned. 

“I’m not saying that doesn’t occur,” she mentioned, explaining that it has occurred with any state or federal funding that has ever been made obtainable. “However these are individuals who can’t afford even $20 for blood stress medicine as a result of each bit of cash they get goes to lease and utilities. Plenty of them don’t know what they’re going to do.”

The top of the federal advantages is simply the most recent of latest challenges for Oklahomans relating to coping with unemployment insurance coverage. Final fall, the pandemic and points with widespread fraud created a backlog in adjudicated claims, which prompted some unemployed Oklahomans to attend as much as three months earlier than receiving advantages. At present, the common wait time for a declare to be adjudicated is 14 days, however as Robinson-Guthrie identified, for individuals who waited longer than a month when the backlog was at its top, it’s seemingly too late; they’ve already missed lease, utilities and different fundamental bills.

“You don’t get something (whereas in adjudication),” Robinson-Guthrie mentioned. “That’s what folks don’t perceive. They preserve saying that the FPUC and PUA funds are stopping folks from going again to work and that persons are lazy, however they don’t notice you must battle for unemployment.”

Jacks, who doesn’t qualify for conventional unemployment insurance coverage, mentioned her ex-husband can seemingly take their two ladies when she loses her house. However her plans embrace a truck and a tent.

“I don’t belief the federal government, I don’t,” she mentioned. “As a result of proper now I see too many individuals hurting, and struggling, and this isn’t how life is meant to be – fearful about whether or not you bought a roof, meals, in case your youngsters are secure – life shouldn’t be a battle day by day for survival.”

She mentioned she will be able to perceive wanting to finish the extra $300 from FPUC on high of standard advantages, however that ending the PUA, which was the one fund serving to the self-employed, is inflicting pointless hurt with out consideration for what’s going to occur to individuals who relied on it.

“The advantages are gone. They’re gone,” Jacks mentioned, elaborating that she had been utilizing the funds to assist her enhance her enterprise within the long-term. “I used to be paying my approach to take some courses, as a result of with that, I used to be including in frequency therapeutic, sound tub therapies and vibrational therapeutic.”

She has misplaced monitor of what number of job functions and resumes she has submitted however has utilized for all types of positions, similar to a butcher, a job she had within the Nineties. She’s hardly ever heard again, aside from a number of emails telling her the employers went with another person. Welding isn’t an possibility anymore due to nerve harm in her fingers.

“I voted for (Stitt) too, if that issues,” she mentioned in between resigned chuckles. “I’ll put it this manner: If elections had been right now, I might not vote for him once more.”

Debi Jacks took a 12 months off of labor in 2019 to deal with her son’s dying and he or she hasn’t been capable of finding a brand new job since. Jacks’ lease was coated by pandemic reduction cash by means of June however she has been unable to pay her July lease and fears her landlord will finally evict her and her two daughters if she doesn’t discover work quickly. (Whitney Bryen/Oklahoma Watch)

Oklahoma’s unemployment ranges have recovered from the pandemic at a quicker tempo than the remainder of the nation. The state’s unemployment rate is 4%, which is considerably decrease than the 13% it was in 2022, however not fairly the three% it was in 2019. The unemployment charge for the U.S. spiked from 3.7% in 2019, to 14% in April 2022, and was again down to five.8% as of Could 2022.

The labor participation rate in Oklahoma is 60.7%, fractionally decrease than it was earlier than the pandemic and a full proportion level larger than it was final spring. The nationwide charge, which was some extent larger than the state’s earlier than the pandemic, has had related fluctuations, however has not recovered as shortly as Oklahoma’s.

The unemployment charge counts those that are unemployed and searching for a job, whereas the labor participation charge counts people who find themselves employed or unemployed and searching for a job. If somebody shouldn’t be searching for a job they aren’t counted within the labor pressure participation charge. Chad Wilkerson, chief economist of the Oklahoma Metropolis department of the Kansas Metropolis Federal Reserve, mentioned that alone the charges aren’t going to clarify the standing of Oklahoma’s labor market, however when thought-about collectively they supply a greater image. 

Wilkerson mentioned the truth that Oklahoma’s unemployment and labor participation charges are each near pre-pandemic ranges – one thing that isn’t true for the nation as an entire – means the labor market on this state is tight.

“There aren’t as many individuals on the sidelines if you’ll, both not working or not within the labor pressure relative to the latest previous as within the nation,” he mentioned. “If you happen to’re getting unemployment insurance coverage, I feel you technically need to be searching for a job, which implies you’re counted within the labor pressure participation charge. So, to be getting the advantages, you’re within the labor pressure. I don’t assume that altering that may have an effect on what the labor pressure participation charge is.”

Which means employers like Riesenburg would possibly get a few of their workers to return to work, inflicting the unemployment charge to decrease whereas the labor participation stays the place it’s.

However Riesenburg acknowledged that unemployment advantages aren’t the one cause companies within the service and hospitality industries are having hassle discovering staff. He mentioned restaurateurs in Oklahoma Metropolis know that the explosion of the medical marijuana trade has pulled staff away from companies like his.

“The vast majority of the workers that they employed for the dispensaries and the cultivating locations and the place they develop it and all that, got here from the hospitality trade,” he mentioned. “And so they’re being paid money, and so they’re being paid extra.”

He mentioned he is aware of of no less than two of his personal workers who’ve transitioned to the hashish trade after leaving his restaurant, and that fellow restaurateurs are seeing an identical pattern. He mentioned he discovered by means of rumour and information experiences that some hashish companies use solely money as a consequence of difficulties with getting banks to work with their cash, and eventually skilled it firsthand when the restaurant was paid in money for a catering service by a dispensary. 

Rep. Monroe Nichols, D-Tulsa, mentioned there are two foremost causes folks haven’t returned to work: They’ve both discovered work elsewhere or wages within the state are too low.

“Why must you make extra on unemployment than you’d make for those who had been working?” he mentioned, explaining that the minimal wage in Oklahoma hasn’t modified because it adopted the federal customary of $7.25 in 2008.

Riensenburg mentioned among the pushback to elevating wages at native eateries like his is that the pandemic not solely prompted a staffing scarcity, but it surely elevated the costs of every little thing wanted to maintain a full restaurant, bar and brewery operating. Rising wages would imply Riensburg must increase menu costs.

“If $15 an hour was the minimal, then your honey-pepper bacon burger goes to price you $19 (as an alternative of $9.89),” he mentioned. “The margins aren’t that nice on this trade.”

Riesenburg mentioned he pays his waitstaff and bartenders the minimal $2.15 hourly charge or extra. After suggestions, he mentioned his waitstaff make between $16 and $18 per hour, whereas bartenders make between $20 and $22 {dollars} per hour.  

Proper earlier than the advantages ended, Oklahomans who certified for conventional unemployment insurance coverage obtained weekly funds equal to 1/twenty third of their wages within the highest paid quarter of the bottom interval, as much as a most of $539, plus $300 from the Federal Pandemic Unemployment Compensation program. With the utmost attainable payout being $839 per week, somebody within the service trade would possibly make the identical quantity from unemployment as they might after suggestions and wages are added collectively. Riesenburg mentioned that with the utmost quantity being lower to $539, his staff are much less more likely to keep unemployed.

“I feel one factor that just about actually will occur is a few folks will return to work as a result of the unemployment insurance coverage is much less,” Wilkerson mentioned. “However on the similar time, there additionally will probably be a share of people that don’t, as a result of that’s not what’s protecting them from working within the first place.”

Jacks is one in all 103,300 Oklahomans within the workforce nonetheless struggling to discover a job, whereas 70,800 extra stay uncounted within the workforce in any respect. She signed her subsequent 12 months’s lease and paid for July’s utilities as a result of it was the one manner she might purchase herself extra time, realizing she doesn’t have the cash to pay the lease.

“I’ve been attempting for a job for over a 12 months and I’m actually shocked I haven’t discovered something,” she mentioned. “Me and my youngsters might very simply grow to be homeless.”

Editor’s be aware: This story has been up to date to mirror the present common wait time for the adjudication of unemployment claims, which is 14 days.

Lionel Ramos is a Report for America corps member who covers race and fairness for Oklahoma Watch. Contact him at (210) 416-3672 or [email protected]. Observe him on Twitter at @LionelRamos21


Assist our publication

On daily basis we attempt to supply journalism that issues — tales that strengthen accountability and transparency, present worth and resonate with readers such as you.


This work is crucial to a better-informed neighborhood and a wholesome democracy. However it isn’t attainable with out your assist.